2 very different Japanese dining experiences

May 04, 2014,23:55 PM
 











Yes, I’ve heard you say all Japanese restaurants are essentially the same. They all serve raw fish with rice . Possibly some cooked pieces of beef or salmon and miso soup is always on the menu. The sake is essentially all much the same and although the quality of the food varies enormously , you know what you are going to eat. Well…. Whilst in NYC and Boston we visited two very different restaurants. I will try and give some idea of the food, although to be honest, I cannot remember exactly what we ate . My pictures are taken with a iPhone are not spectacular but hopefully you will get the idea. The first restaurant is called Sushi Nakazawa. The chef is from Japan and worked for a gentleman called Jiro. If that rings a bell , it is because there was amovie made about him called Jiro Dreams of Sushi- well worth seeing. It is a fixed 20 course omakase menu of only Nigiri Sushi. Nothing wlse. No miso soup , no sashimi, no habatchi, no tempura… you get the idea only Nigiri Sushi. Now in normal circumstances this would be boring and tedious but no , Mr Nakazawa manages to slightly change each serving by changing the fish or even by changing the cut of the fish. Two pieces of sushi from the same Bluefin Tuna is very different dependant on where the meat is taken from.There is a prawn ( shrimp) sushi, eel sushi and many other types of fish , some of which I have never heard of.

















Delcious- 2 cuts from bluefin

Delcious- 2 cuts from bluefin


Not my favourite dish

Not my favourite dish










I though of it as essentially a blind tasting of sushi as there are no real visual clues. The dishes all look much the same , the difference being the different fishes he uses. One or two of the courses uses a smoked fish and this is incredible. No extra Soy or wasabi is offered and is essentially frowned upon. The service is superb with the waiter explaining each course in detail.




 In Boston we ate at O Ya. A totally different experience. Similar to N-Naka in Los Angeles. Here there are 3 choices 
1. Premium chefs menu of about 15 courses 
2. Regular chefs menu of a similar number 
3. A la carte 
 We chose number 3 and essentially chose off the sushi/ sashimi menu. You could also order cooked pieces as well. There are 50 courses from the sushi/ sashimi menu and another 43 courses to order from the other menu. The food is incredibly well presented and again the waiters are extremely well versed with the food and are very helpful in negotiating your way through the menu. If you order something and do not like it ( very uncommon ) they will not charge for this course.

We started off with a delicious mushroom miso broth. Full of depth and flavour.

We started off with a delicious mushroom miso broth. Full of depth and flavour.


Kumamato oyster with watermelon and cucumber

Kumamato oyster with watermelon and cucumber

































Home smoked wagyu












1. Kumamato oyster with watermelon and cucumber 2. Bluefin maguro 3. Peruvian style Bluefin ChutoroTataki- my wife’s favourite- we ordered seconds! 4. Negihama – yellowtail with scallion 5. Hamachi belly with sea urchin 6. wild santa Barbara spot prawn- with garlic butter , white soy and yuzu 7. Bluefin magoro with caramalised onion and foie gras ponzu- one of my favourites 8. Bluefin chatoro- with a mayonnaise and sesame 9. Home smoked wagyu 10. Hamachi tartare- very spicey with a chilli oil 11. Arctic char- with a sesame brittle and aioli 12. Shima aji- with santa barabara sea urchin 13. Scallop and foie gras- another favourite You get the idea. All very delicious with deep intense flavours , although not overpowering relative to the underlying seafood or meat. Some of the pictures may not correspond to the above meal but even though the pictures are all not very good , they do convey the idea of the food. Both restaurants, although very different are well worth a visit.

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

re: experiences

 
 By: DRMW : May 5th, 2014-00:12
I'm not a fan of uni or amaebi but when it's good I'll eat it. How were the scallops at Sushi Nakazawa? I like those plates that O Ya used for their dishes, glad to hear that the staff knew the menu! -MW

cannot specifically remember the scallops

 
 By: watch-guy.com : May 5th, 2014-19:11
But the fish was all exceptionally fresh and well prepared The presentation at O ya was exceptional ( incl the crockery) Interestingly the decor at Sushi nakazawa was much more formal Julian

comparing the two experiences

 
 By: ED209 : May 5th, 2014-19:48
Both dining experiences look great. Did you like the Boston place better than N Naka in LA? Regards, ED-209

Please forgive my frankness but whoever told you

 
 By: ThomasM : May 7th, 2014-15:51
"Yes, I’ve heard you say all Japanese restaurants are essentially the same. They all serve raw fish with rice . Possibly some cooked pieces of beef or salmon and miso soup is always on the menu. The sake is essentially all much the same and although the q...